Explore the ideological contrasts between Mahatma Gandhi and Subhas Chandra Bose, focusing on their differing approaches to non-violence, socialism, and strategies for Indian independence.
Ideological Differences: Mutual Respect
Gandhi’s Praise: Gandhi praised Bose as a "Prince among the Patriots" and acknowledged his bravery and service.
Bose’s Respect: Bose respected Gandhi’s role as "The Father of Our Nation" and admired his contributions to India's freedom.
Socialism
Gandhi’s View: Preferred a non-industrial, village-based socialism.
Bose’s View: Considered a state-centric approach involving industrialization.
Religious and Social Views
Common Beliefs: Both were religious and opposed communism, worked against untouchability, and supported women’s rights.
Differences: Their methods and ideologies on these issues differed significantly.
Non-Violence versus Militant Approach
Gandhi’s Philosophy: Advocated for non-violence (ahimsa) and civil disobedience, seeing violence as counterproductive.
Bose’s Philosophy: Believed non-violence alone was inadequate, advocating militant resistance and revolution.
Means and Ends
Bose’s Pragmatism: Used weaknesses of the British and aligned with Axis powers to advance India's freedom, though he did not align with their racial or capitalist views.
Gandhi’s Ethics: Emphasized that means must align with moral principles, rejecting associations with Fascist or Nazi ideologies.
Form of Government
Bose’s Views: Initially supportive of democracy, later suggested an authoritarian system for nation-building, admiring aspects of Fascism for its discipline.
Gandhi’s Views: Favored a decentralized, village-based system (Ramrajya) with moral and ethical self-governance, opposing centralized power.
Militarism
Bose’s Attraction: Interested in military discipline and utilized military-style formations and training.
Gandhi’s Opposition: Fundamentally opposed militarism, viewing it as corrupting and advocating for minimal defense forces.
Ideas on Economy
Gandhi’s Economic Vision: Supported a decentralized, village-based economy, opposing capitalism and large-scale industrialization.
Bose’s Economic Vision: Favored industrialization and state control for economic progress, inspired by Soviet economic policies.
Religion
Gandhi: Believed God embodies Truth, Love, and Conscience, seeing all religions as paths to the same truth. He viewed serving the poor as the highest worship.
Bose: Promoted religious equality, used Hindu symbols for support, advocated for a secular state with religion as a private matter, and his INA was inclusive of all religions.
Caste and Untouchability
Gandhi: Aimed to eliminate untouchability while maintaining the varna system as a means of social harmony.
Bose: Rejected the caste system and supported a classless, egalitarian society, advocating for inter-caste marriages and opposing untouchability.
Women
Gandhi: Worked to uplift women, opposed child marriage and dowry, supported women's equality but had traditional views on gender roles.
Bose: Took a progressive approach, encouraged women’s participation in public life, established the Rani of Jhansi Regiment in the INA, and advocated for women's education and equal opportunities.
Education
Gandhi’s Views: Rejected English education, supported local languages, free and compulsory education, holistic approach including moral and spiritual education, and Nai Talim (Basic Education) integrating academics with manual labor.
Bose’s Views: Focused on higher education, particularly in technical and scientific fields, advocating for sending students abroad for specialized training to foster industrial development.
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By continuing to browse, you agree to our use of cookies. Please review our
Privacy Policy and
Terms of Use for more information.
Stay focused & Stay away from distractions
At Studento, we make sure you always remain focused on your studies
